The Independent Market Observer

Are There Signs of a Potential Market Crash in the Data?

Posted by Brad McMillan, CFA®, CFP®

Find me on:

This entry was posted on Oct 1, 2015 4:00:55 PM

and tagged Investing

Leave a comment

market crashIn a continuation of my post from yesterday, I am not aware of any single indicator that can tell us when a market crash will occur. (I wish I were!) So, what I have done is reviewed previous significant market downturns and determined some common contributory factors that make sense in theory, as well as empirically.

Identifying past downturns

The following chart shows the change, year-on-year, in the S&P 500 Index and provides a nice summary of declines over the past 40 years. If we limit our view to instances when the decline was greater than 20 percent or so, we get the following periods:

  • 1983–1984
  • 1987
  • 2000–2001
  • 2008–2009

market crash

This is a pretty good sample, so let’s take a look at some potential factors that may have contributed to each market crash. Today, I’ll focus on market-based indicators, and tomorrow I’ll take a look at more general gauges. Next week, I’ll combine them to see what the ensemble indicates about the near future of the market.

Valuation changes

In theory, changes in how investors value the market should show up in actual prices, and the change in investor opinion should precede that price change. The following chart is not all that clear, but the point I want to make is that, for the two events we can see most clearly (2000 and 2008), the rate of change of the Shiller P/E did start declining well before prices dropped the most on a year-to-year basis. You can also see this, although less clearly, in 1983 and 1987. That said, there have also been false alarms, such as in 2004and for the past couple of years.

Even so, with the growth rate of the Shiller P/E moving into negative territory in recent months, this metric seems to suggest that a sharper decline is possible

Shiller P/E

Margin debt in the markets

Typically, as markets rise, people borrow more and more until the bubble pops, and they have to sell to pay their loans. We should therefore, in theory, be able to track spikes in margin debt and use that as an indicator for a potential crash.

margin debt

In practice, the relationship is less clear cut. Although we did see spikes in margin borrowing in 2000 and 2008, which collapsed before the market dropped, recently we have seen a slow decline in the growth rate of debt, rather than a spike.

market debt

In fact, in absolute terms, margin debt has topped out and started to decline, even as the market has pulled back. This indicator seems to show that while margin debt remains high, the market has not seen the kind of spiked borrowing that in the past led to a large correction.

The Buffett indicator

The final market indicator today is the change in the ratio of market capitalization to GDP—an indicator favored by Warren Buffett. If investors are optimistic, in theory, they will bid up stocks to a higher level, but a change in that optimism will show up before a significant price decline.

Looking at the past 20 years, we can see that a drop in the annual change of the market cap-to-GDP ratio to below zero did precede the declines in 2000 and 2008. As we are moving into a similar scenario right now, this suggests that a significant decline is possible. Earlier periods are less predictive, but the relationship remains.

buffett indicator

Alert readers will note that these metrics show up in the Bubble Trouble post, last updated a couple of months ago. This is deliberate—warning indicators can, hopefully, be used in a proactive way as well.

The picture remains unclear

So, what have we got? A mixed set of indicators, based on the market, and while they are suggestive, they are not sufficient on their own to determine whether we’ll see another market crash. Tomorrow, therefore, we will look at a broader array of warning signs to try to get a clearer picture.

The S&P 500 Index is a broad-based measurement of changes in stock market conditions based on the average performance of 500 widely held common stocks. 


Subscribe via Email

New call-to-action
Crash-Test Investing

Hot Topics



New Call-to-action

Conversations

Archives

see all

Subscribe


Disclosure

The information on this website is intended for informational/educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice, a solicitation, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or investment product. Please contact your financial professional for more information specific to your situation.

Certain sections of this commentary contain forward-looking statements that are based on our reasonable expectations, estimates, projections, and assumptions. Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve certain risks and uncertainties, which are difficult to predict. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets.

The S&P 500 Index is a broad-based measurement of changes in stock market conditions based on the average performance of 500 widely held common stocks. All indices are unmanaged and investors cannot invest directly in an index.

The MSCI EAFE (Europe, Australia, Far East) Index is a free float‐adjusted market capitalization index that is designed to measure the equity market performance of developed markets, excluding the U.S. and Canada. The MSCI EAFE Index consists of 21 developed market country indices.

One basis point (bp) is equal to 1/100th of 1 percent, or 0.01 percent.

The VIX (CBOE Volatility Index) measures the market’s expectation of 30-day volatility across a wide range of S&P 500 options.

The forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio divides the current share price of the index by its estimated future earnings.

Third-party links are provided to you as a courtesy. We make no representation as to the completeness or accuracy of information provided on these websites. Information on such sites, including third-party links contained within, should not be construed as an endorsement or adoption by Commonwealth of any kind. You should consult with a financial advisor regarding your specific situation.

Member FINRASIPC

Please review our Terms of Use

Commonwealth Financial Network®